Free senior care help for families in Toledo, Lucas County and Wood County.
Call (419) 616-9799
Toledo Senior Advisor(419) 616-9799

Otterbein Monclova

Nursing home certified for Medicare and Medicaid in Monclova, Lucas County, Ohio

2 CMS overall stars
60 certified beds
14 deficiencies, latest cycle
Quick answer

Otterbein Monclova (5069 Otterbein Way, Monclova, Lucas County) is a Medicare- and Medicaid-certified nursing home with 60 certified beds, licensed by the Ohio Department of Health as State ID 2503N. CMS gives Otterbein Monclova 2 of 5 stars overall, per the Care Compare release dated October 1, 2026.

Home›Directory›Nursing homes›Otterbein Monclova
At a glance

Otterbein Monclova (5069 Otterbein Way, Monclova, Lucas County) is a Medicare- and Medicaid-certified nursing home with 60 certified beds, licensed by the Ohio Department of Health as State ID 2503N. CMS gives Otterbein Monclova 2 of 5 stars overall, per the Care Compare release dated October 1, 2026.

What star rating does CMS give Otterbein Monclova in Monclova, OH?

CMS gives Otterbein Monclova 2 of 5 stars overall; its sub-ratings are 2 for health inspections, 3 for staffing and 4 for quality measures, each out of five.

MeasureFigure
Overall (CMS)2 of 5
Health inspections (CMS)2 of 5
Staffing (CMS)3 of 5
Quality measures (CMS)4 of 5
Certified beds / residents per day60 / 53.0
CMS provider nameOtterbein Monclova
Ownership typeGovernment - Federal
Chain (per CMS)Otterbein Seniorlife (20 facilities)
Certified for Medicare and Medicaid sinceMay 20, 2008
ODH licenseState ID 2503N, 60 licensed beds

About 53 residents a day means roughly 88% of its certified beds are in use, in line with the 90% median for certified homes in Lucas and Wood counties.

How many health deficiencies does Otterbein Monclova have?

March 27, 2025 is the date of Otterbein Monclova's newest standard survey in Care Compare, with 14 health deficiencies: 12 on the routine visit, 4 tied to complaints.

One cycle earlier, on November 21, 2022, CMS counted 20 deficiencies; infection-control reviews contributed 0 more. With a two-county median of 12, the newest count is worse than most Toledo-area homes.

CMS shows 1 fine totaling $47,171 and 0 payment denials in its three-year penalty window.

What do staffing and turnover look like at Otterbein Monclova?

Each resident at Otterbein Monclova gets about 4.41 hours of nursing staff time daily (higher than the Lucas-Wood median of 3.69), including 0.42 RN hours (lower than the Lucas-Wood median of 0.58).

Weekend nurse staffing comes to 4.12 hours per resident-day. Total nursing turnover is 51.0%, higher than the Lucas-Wood median of 49.5%, and RN turnover 80.0%. 0 administrators left during CMS's measurement period.

How does Otterbein Monclova compare with homes nearby?

With 60 certified beds it is smaller than the Lucas County median of 88 licensed nursing home beds. The Lakes of Monclova in Maumee is the closest other certified home, about 1.1 miles away in a straight line, rated 5 of 5 by CMS.

FacilityMiles awayLicensed bedsCMS overall ratingLast CMS health inspectionDeficiencies cited
The Lakes of Monclova
6935 Monclova Road, 43537
1.1605 of 5April 30, 20264
Addison Heights Health and Rehabilitation Center
3600 Butz Road, 43537
2.0902 of 5September 15, 202531
Ridgewood Manor
3231 Manley Road, 43537
2.7903 of 5December 4, 20255
Elizabeth Scott Community
2720 Albon Road, 43537
3.2605 of 5June 11, 20262
Astoria Place of Waterville LLC
555 Anthony Wayne Trail, 43566
4.0901 of 5August 27, 202522

Where is Otterbein Monclova, and what else is on its campus?

Otterbein Monclova is located in Monclova, Lucas County; University of Toledo Medical Center is the nearest general hospital on CMS's list, about 6.3 miles away by straight line.

Next is Wood County Hospital, around 10.1 miles away. Distances are straight-line, not driving.

What should we ask Otterbein Monclova before admission?

Work from the federal data first: ask to see the correction plan for the 14 deficiencies from March 27, 2025 and what has changed on the floor.

  • At 51.0%, turnover is above the Lucas-Wood median; ask how many shifts rely on agency nurses and aides.
  • Ask what led to $47,171 in federal fines and whether the cause is resolved.
  • Occupancy runs about 88%; ask where the open beds are and why they are open.
  • CMS records a resident council; ask how often it meets and if families can join.
  • If Medicaid may take over, confirm that Otterbein Monclova accepts Ohio Medicaid for long-term residents and whether a payer change means a room change.
Source: Ohio Department of Health, EID Facility Listing by County and license detail, retrieved November 15, 2026 (publicapps.odh.ohio.gov); CMS Care Compare Provider Information, data as of October 1, 2026 (data.cms.gov). Star ratings are CMS's own and satisfaction scores are the state survey's; we do not rate facilities.

Not sure where to start?

Answer five questions and a local advisor will come back with senior care options in Toledo, Lucas County and Wood County that fit your situation and budget. It is free, and there is no obligation.

Find care options
Find Facilities Near You