Free senior care help for families in Toledo, Lucas County and Wood County.
Call (419) 616-9799
Toledo Senior Advisor(419) 616-9799

Otterbein-Portage Valley

Nursing home certified for Medicare and Medicaid in Pemberville, Wood County, Ohio

4 CMS overall stars
50 certified beds
8 deficiencies, latest cycle
Quick answer

Otterbein-Portage Valley (20311 Pemberville Road, Pemberville, Wood County) is a Medicare- and Medicaid-certified nursing home with 50 certified beds, licensed by the Ohio Department of Health as State ID 1737N. CMS gives Otterbein-Portage Valley 4 of 5 stars overall, per the Care Compare release dated October 1, 2026.

Home›Directory›Nursing homes›Otterbein-Portage Valley
At a glance

Otterbein-Portage Valley (20311 Pemberville Road, Pemberville, Wood County) is a Medicare- and Medicaid-certified nursing home with 50 certified beds, licensed by the Ohio Department of Health as State ID 1737N. CMS gives Otterbein-Portage Valley 4 of 5 stars overall, per the Care Compare release dated October 1, 2026.

How does Otterbein-Portage Valley score on Medicare Care Compare?

CMS gives Otterbein-Portage Valley 4 of 5 stars overall; its sub-ratings are 3 for health inspections, 3 for staffing and 5 for quality measures, each out of five.

MeasureFigure
Overall (CMS)4 of 5
Health inspections (CMS)3 of 5
Staffing (CMS)3 of 5
Quality measures (CMS)5 of 5
Certified beds / residents per day50 / 46.6
CMS provider nameOtterbein Portage Valley
Ownership typeNon profit - Corporation
Chain (per CMS)Otterbein Seniorlife (20 facilities)
Certified for Medicare and Medicaid sinceDecember 15, 1981
ODH licenseState ID 1737N, 50 licensed beds

About 47 residents a day means roughly 93% of its certified beds are in use, higher than the 90% median for certified homes in Lucas and Wood counties.

What problems did inspectors find at Otterbein-Portage Valley?

June 18, 2025 is the date of Otterbein-Portage Valley's newest standard survey in Care Compare, with 8 health deficiencies: 5 on the routine visit, 5 tied to complaints.

The prior cycle (November 28, 2022) showed 17 deficiencies, and infection-control checks added 0 citations. Across certified homes in Lucas and Wood counties the latest-cycle median is 12, so Otterbein-Portage Valley lands at or below the local middle.

CMS shows no fines in its three-year penalty window and 0 payment denials.

What do staffing and turnover look like at Otterbein-Portage Valley?

Staffing records filed with CMS show 3.34 nurse hours per resident per day at Otterbein-Portage Valley, lower than the Lucas-Wood median of 3.69; registered nurses provide 0.72 of them, higher than the Lucas-Wood median of 0.58.

Weekend nurse staffing comes to 3.03 hours per resident-day. Total nursing turnover is 49.1%, about even with the two-county median of 49.5%, and RN turnover 45.5%. 0 administrators left during CMS's measurement period.

How does Otterbein-Portage Valley compare with homes nearby?

With 50 certified beds it is smaller than the Wood County median of 60 licensed nursing home beds. Founders Care & Rehabilitation in Perrysburg is the closest other certified home, about 9.2 miles away in a straight line, rated 2 of 5 by CMS.

FacilityMiles awayLicensed bedsCMS overall ratingLast CMS health inspectionDeficiencies cited
Founders Care & Rehabilitation
28546 Starbright Boulevard, 43551
9.2752 of 5April 24, 202623
The Willows at Bowling Green
525 S Dunbridge Road, 43402
9.4505 of 5December 31, 20251
Three Meadows Post Acute
10540 Fremont Pike, 43551
10.01201 of 5May 15, 202524
St Clare Commons
12469 Five Point Road, 43551
10.4603 of 5June 26, 202519
The Manor at Perrysburg
250 Manor Drive, 43551
10.61113 of 5August 21, 202515

Where is Otterbein-Portage Valley, and what else is on its campus?

Otterbein-Portage Valley is located in Pemberville, Wood County; Wood County Hospital is the nearest general hospital on CMS's list, about 10.6 miles away by straight line.

Next is University of Toledo Medical Center, around 14.1 miles away. Distances are straight-line, not driving.

ODH licenses assisted living at the same address too: Otterbein-Portage Valley (RCF license, 204 beds). CMS flags the home as part of a continuing care retirement community.

What should we ask Otterbein-Portage Valley before admission?

Work from the federal data first: read the complete June 18, 2025 statement of deficiencies, even though 8 deficiencies is modest for the area.

  • Turnover of 49.1% is at or below the local median; ask which nurses have been on nights longest.
  • With occupancy near 93%, ask about the wait list and whether short-term rehab has its own hall.
  • CMS records a resident council; ask how often it meets and if families can join.
  • If Medicaid may take over, confirm that Otterbein-Portage Valley accepts Ohio Medicaid for long-term residents and whether a payer change means a room change.
Source: Ohio Department of Health, EID Facility Listing by County and license detail, retrieved November 15, 2026 (publicapps.odh.ohio.gov); CMS Care Compare Provider Information, data as of October 1, 2026 (data.cms.gov). Star ratings are CMS's own and satisfaction scores are the state survey's; we do not rate facilities.

Not sure where to start?

Answer five questions and a local advisor will come back with senior care options in Toledo, Lucas County and Wood County that fit your situation and budget. It is free, and there is no obligation.

Find care options
Find Facilities Near You